Show 5.0 out of 5 stars Hospital Emergency Planning - Tough Choices Fink, S. (2013). Five days at Memorial: Life and death in a storm-ravaged hospital . Crown Publishers.Dr. Sheri Fink’s work explores the impact of crises on health care and is informed by her background as an MD and former relief worker in disaster and conflict zones. Fink received a PhD in Neuroscience and an MD from Stanford University.Part 1 describes what happened during Hurricane Katrina at Memorial Medical Center. Although there were lessons learned from prior hurricanes, flooding events, and scenario planning, necessary expenditures were not allocated to make changes or to create scenario specific response plans pertinent to preparedness, coordination, and evacuation. Reading the five days described by Fink is like watching a train wreck as conditions worsened and doctors and nurses strived to take care of seriously ill patients. When do normal hospital operations cease replaced by emergency conditions where standard rules and protocols simply are not feasible? This is a story about a hospital filled with doctors, nurses, patients, family members, and pets with no power, rising waters, deteriorating conditions, and poor evacuation protocols. Tenet Healthcare, portrayed as a corporate owner with no real incident command system in place for emergencies, no preexisting contracts with medical transporters, etc., relied on government resources to respond to the emergency. Doctors met to establish a protocol for prioritizing patients with those with DNR order prioritized last for evacuation.According to Fink, "Concepts of triage and medical rationing are a barometer of how those in power in society value human life." (p. 136) But what happens in an emergency when choices may be necessary? What triage systems exist to help responders make decisions? Fink noted, "[Dr. Anna] Pou and her colleagues had little if any training in triage systems and were not guided by any particular protocol" (p. 139). 45 deceased were found in the hospital following Hurricane Katrina. Toxicology reports indicated high concentrations of morphine and other drugs in some patients suggesting that some patients were euthanized.Part 2 describes the aftermath including investigations, arrests, and accusations of Dr. Anna Pou and nurses who were asserted to have committed euthanasia. Reviews with images
Top reviews from the United StatesThere was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.Reviewed in the United States 🇺🇸 on October 28, 2022 There were so many feelings for this book. I can't believe what they went through. I can't believe how much they did. Carrying people down so many flights of stairs then out to the ramps and UP flights of stairs to get them evacuated... I don't have words for the strength these people showed. Then the lack of each and every get to have a clear organized plan... From the hospital to the government to the relief agencies. Balls were dropped on every get involved with everyone pointing fingers at each other. I have no words. The book is well written. It is easy as a people to say, I would do this..." Or "I would never..." But just as was quoted in the book, you can't even imagine this situation unless you had been there. As someone who believes in death with dignity I can understand the thoughts that these people faced. And yet one is left to wonder if things had been done differently would it have been necessary? That is the testament to this author. When you can see and feel both sides of the situation and twirly not know what you would have done. Reviewed in the United States 🇺🇸 on August 29, 2022 Fink, S. (2013). Five days at Memorial: Life and death in a storm-ravaged hospital . Crown Publishers. Dr. Sheri Fink’s work explores the impact of crises on health care and is informed by her background as an MD and former relief worker in disaster and conflict zones. Fink received a PhD in Neuroscience and an MD from Stanford University. Part 1 describes what happened during Hurricane Katrina at Memorial Medical Center. Although there were lessons learned from prior hurricanes, flooding events, and scenario planning, necessary expenditures were not allocated to make changes or to create scenario specific response plans pertinent to preparedness, coordination, and evacuation. Reading the five days described by Fink is like watching a train wreck as conditions worsened and doctors and nurses strived to take care of seriously ill patients. When do normal hospital operations cease replaced by emergency conditions where standard rules and protocols simply are not feasible? This is a story about a hospital filled with doctors, nurses, patients, family members, and pets with no power, rising waters, deteriorating conditions, and poor evacuation protocols. Tenet Healthcare, portrayed as a corporate owner with no real incident command system in place for emergencies, no preexisting contracts with medical transporters, etc., relied on government resources to respond to the emergency. Doctors met to establish a protocol for prioritizing patients with those with DNR order prioritized last for evacuation. According to Fink, "Concepts of triage and medical rationing are a barometer of how those in power in society value human life." (p. 136) But what happens in an emergency when choices may be necessary? What triage systems exist to help responders make decisions? Fink noted, "[Dr. Anna] Pou and her colleagues had little if any training in triage systems and were not guided by any particular protocol" (p. 139). 45 deceased were found in the hospital following Hurricane Katrina. Toxicology reports indicated high concentrations of morphine and other drugs in some patients suggesting that some patients were euthanized. Part 2 describes the aftermath including investigations, arrests, and accusations of Dr. Anna Pou and nurses who were asserted to have committed euthanasia. 5.0 out of 5 stars Hospital Emergency Planning - Tough Choices Fink, S. (2013). Five days at Memorial: Life and death in a storm-ravaged hospital . Crown Publishers. Dr. Sheri Fink’s work explores the impact of crises on health care and is informed by her background as an MD and former relief worker in disaster and conflict zones. Fink received a PhD in Neuroscience and an MD from Stanford University. Part 1 describes what happened during Hurricane Katrina at Memorial Medical Center. Although there were lessons learned from prior hurricanes, flooding events, and scenario planning, necessary expenditures were not allocated to make changes or to create scenario specific response plans pertinent to preparedness, coordination, and evacuation. Reading the five days described by Fink is like watching a train wreck as conditions worsened and doctors and nurses strived to take care of seriously ill patients. When do normal hospital operations cease replaced by emergency conditions where standard rules and protocols simply are not feasible? This is a story about a hospital filled with doctors, nurses, patients, family members, and pets with no power, rising waters, deteriorating conditions, and poor evacuation protocols. Tenet Healthcare, portrayed as a corporate owner with no real incident command system in place for emergencies, no preexisting contracts with medical transporters, etc., relied on government resources to respond to the emergency. Doctors met to establish a protocol for prioritizing patients with those with DNR order prioritized last for evacuation. According to Fink, "Concepts of triage and medical rationing are a barometer of how those in power in society value human life." (p. 136) But what happens in an emergency when choices may be necessary? What triage systems exist to help responders make decisions? Fink noted, "[Dr. Anna] Pou and her colleagues had little if any training in triage systems and were not guided by any particular protocol" (p. 139). 45 deceased were found in the hospital following Hurricane Katrina. Toxicology reports indicated high concentrations of morphine and other drugs in some patients suggesting that some patients were euthanized. Part 2 describes the aftermath including investigations, arrests, and accusations of Dr. Anna Pou and nurses who were asserted to have committed euthanasia. Images in this review Reviewed in the United States 🇺🇸 on October 24, 2022 I was inspired to read this book after watching the limited series on Apple TV+ that was based on it. There are some stunning revelations in this book that weren’t even mentioned in the series. If you like investigative journalism, this is a must read. Another reviewer above basically called this book fake news but it is very clear they did not read this book and just want to discourage others from reading it as well. The author Sheri Fink who won the Pulitzer Prize for her reporting on this event, gives you the facts of the investigation and asks important questions without drawing conclusions or offering an opinion. There are 62 pages of notes and references on the research put into the writing of this book. I couldn’t put this book down. This story needed to be told. Reviewed in the United States 🇺🇸 on August 27, 2022 After seeing the recent TV series based on this book, I decided to buy and read it. On the plus side, the author Sherri Fink writes very well, and gives readers a compelling account of the
"Five Days" as hospital staff struggled to deal with an impossible situation during Hurricane Katrina. Largely abandoned by City, State, and Federal officials, as well as by Tenet (owner of the hospital), the staff had to make agonizing decisions about survival, including which patients could be saved. Fink focuses much of her attention on one doctor, Anna Pou, who euthanized a number of seriously ill patients (at least according to this book). Although I admire this book, I do have some
criticisms: Top reviews from other countries4.0 out of 5 stars Fascinating and challenging account Reviewed in the United Kingdom 🇬🇧 on September 24, 2014 Divides into three stages. First is the story of the five days up to Sept 1st 2005 after Katrina at Memorial hospital in New Orleans. The full horror and danger of the circumstances are conveyed along with the sheer heroism and devotion to duty which the medical staff showed. Without this knowledge what happened next cannot be understood so it is worth sticking with its confusions and complexities. Second is the account of how the authorities tried to bring one doctor and two nurses to trial for second degree murder on allegations of 'euthanising' patients who could not be rescued from the hospital. I found myself repeatedly pulled in contrary directions and the writer skilfully takes the reader through all the ethical ambivalence of the case with both the medical and non-medical communities divided in their views on what happened and the ultimate grand jury verdict. Third is an interesting and disturbing consideration of the lessons of Katrina and other disasters for our preparedness in the future to meet natural and health crises where medical resources will be limited. 5.0 out of 5 stars Every Nurse, doctor and corporate employee should read this book! Reviewed in the United Kingdom 🇬🇧 on September 20, 2014 I found this book compelling. As a Registered Nurse practising
on the Gulf Coast for forty years I know the system and the terrain and the weather risks. As a Nursing Administrator I had to make decisions about evacuation of patients, transportation and the care of staff during these conditions. I must say I cried and found the situation harrowing. I thank God that I never had to make the ultimate decision these Nurses and Doctors had to contemplate. 5.0 out of 5 stars Very well written, disturbing account. Reviewed in the United Kingdom 🇬🇧 on March 6, 2014 A straight reporting of what went on at Memorial, during and immediately after Hurricane Katrina. 2.0 out of 5 stars Important Story Badly Written Reviewed in the United Kingdom 🇬🇧 on April 30, 2020 This is the story of the Memorial Hospital during Hurricane Katrina. I think it is an important document of public record of what can go wrong during a crisis with poor management however the writing style didn’t appeal to me. I felt it was neither presented as a factual report or written in a story like fashion. The book covers the most dramatic circumstances yet manages to be boring and really hard work. 4.0 out of 5 stars Worth a Read Reviewed in the United Kingdom 🇬🇧 on May 30, 2014 A well researched and thorough account of events. The loss of one star was purely because, whilst the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina was riveting, the legal aspect, for me, was not so. For those who like investigative and legal procedures it would be a five start book. How can I watch 5 days at Memorial?Streaming on Roku. Five Days at Memorial, a drama series starring Vera Farmiga, Cherry Jones, and Cornelius Smith is available to stream now. Watch it on Apple TV on your Roku device.
Is 5 days at Memorial on Amazon Prime?The show is available exclusively on Apple TV+.
Is 5 days at Memorial about charity hospital?The story focused on the events that unfolded in New Orleans' Memorial Medical Center (now Ochsner Baptist Medical Center) when the hospital was flooded and its generators failed in the aftermath of Katrina, drawing particular attention to the euthanasia of numerous patients by the medical and nursing staff.
Is five days at Memorial a movie?Five Days at Memorial is an American disaster medical drama television miniseries based on the 2013 book of the same name by Sheri Fink. The miniseries was developed, written and directed by John Ridley and Carlton Cuse.
|